Year-End Bonuses: Three Numbers to Help You Plan

year end bonuses

Your best people worked hard; the year is winding down, and you want to say thank you in a way that actually means something. Bring on the employee bonuses!

“How much should I give?” isn’t really the question. The real question is: can you afford to, and will you be in good shape in January if you do?

We believe good bonus decisions come from numbers, not a gut feeling. Here are the three numbers we tell clients to look at before writing a single check.

1. Your net profit, not your revenue

Revenue feels good, but it’s not the number that pays the bonus.

If you had a great sales year but your margins decreased, your revenue can be up while your actual profit went down. Higher costs.More overtime. A vendor price hike you absorbed instead of passing it on.  Any of these can impact your bottom line. Bonuses come out of profit, not gross revenue. Look there first.

If you don’t know your net profit off the top of your head, that’s worth calculating before determining bonus amounts. 

2. The true cost of the bonus

A $5,000 bonus doesn’t cost you $5,000. Once you layer in payroll taxes, it’s closer to $5,400 – $5,750, depending on your state and how you structure it. Multiply that across ten employees, and the cost of those bonuses can add up. 

Calculate the “true cost”, payroll taxes and any other payroll costs, and build it into your cash flow projections. That’s the only way to know if the bonus plan holds up, or if it sets you up for a shortfall come January.

3. Your cash reserves after the fact

This is the one people skip, and it’s the one that matters most.

Profit on paper and cash in the bank are not the same thing. You can be profitable and still be cash-poor if money is tied up in receivables or you have a big bill due in January. Before you finalize bonus amounts, ask: if I pay every bonus today, what does my bank balance look like tomorrow? And is that number one you’re comfortable with heading into a new year?

If the answer makes you nervous, that’s not a reason to cancel bonuses altogether. It does give you a reason to think about timing, amount, or structure (cash now vs. a combination of cash and other benefits).

The Lesson Learned

We know none of this is as fun as just picking a number and moving on. But a bonus that’s generous and sustainable beats a bonus that’s generous and creates a January cash crunch every time.

If you’re not sure where your numbers actually stand, that’s what we’re here for. A quick look at your books now can save you a much harder conversation in a few months. What if your current books are a mess and you don’t know where to look? Contact us. We’ll help you find out.